forums

MasterChef Forums » Series 1 Contestants » Julie


Permlink Replies: 138 - Pages: 10 [ Previous | 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ] - Last Post: 27/07/2010 18:40 Last Post By: asd0407 Threads: [ Previous | Next ]
mylittlebillyel...


Posts: 6,233
Joined Forums: 9/02/09
Re: Show is Rigged
Posted: 25/11/2009 18:23   in response to: kledwards in response to: kledwards
thousands before you have said the same.
livreilly

Posts: 1
Joined Forums: 12/04/10
Re: Show is Rigged
Posted: 12/04/2010 10:11   in response to: patgan in response to: patgan
Just finished watching Masterchef and at the start of the series i loved it, however, i soon began to think that it was Julie continously serving sloppy raw dishes and then cried and rambled on about her family. Seriously, who gives a shite, she should of been thrown out of the series at the beginning. I kept thinking each night that Julie would surely be thrown out of this episode, and even doe she cooked raw fish, Julia a talented cook was sent home. Then Justine who i thought might win the show and then Chris who i didnt really like but he is talented. The judges decided earlier in the season that she would sell most books and that is the only reason why she won. The program was fixed and i am disgusted that i spent my evenings watching her breeze her way to the final. Lets hope that celebrity masterchef will be more fair and honest.
theyeahman

Posts: 3
Joined Forums: 12/06/10
Re: Show is Rigged
Posted: 12/06/2010 13:50   in response to: patgan in response to: patgan
Julie won fair and square.

Reason I say this... she won according to the criteria set out by the competition.

Masterchef TV show Criteria:

Must be able to sell books to vast majority of home-style mums.
Must appear to be a nice person without any over confidence.
Does not cook masterchef style meals.
Can make roasts, bake cakes, and serve 1970's style prawn cocktails in a nursing home.
Will not get a job in a kitchen.
Will keep people coming back to the show.
Will do whatever she is told.

If the criteria were to find the best CHEF... then Justine, Julia, Poh or Chris would have won. But that's not what the show is about.

cheers.
asd0407

Posts: 7
Joined Forums: 17/07/09
Re: Show is Rigged
Posted: 27/07/2010 18:38   in response to: theyeahman in response to: theyeahman
Very funny, theyeahman ! I totally agree with all your points except for this one: "Will keep people coming back to the show".
When it became quite clear that they would let Julie win, I stopped watching. I honestly could not bear to witness such a basic homecook win a so called "Master"chef title. But I think they learned for this season's show. This year's winner actually did deserve to win!

Edited by: asd0407 on 27/07/2010 18:39

Edited by: asd0407 on 27/07/2010 18:40

Point your RSS reader here for a feed of the latest messages in all forums